Note: Most are publication dates instead of creation dates.
| 528 | Throne of Glory | Arnulf of Leuven | 1250 |
| 302 | Olivers | Daniel ben Judah | 1404 |
| 301 | John Street | Daniel ben Judah | 1404 |
| 527 | Prince of Light | John Milton | 1629 |
| 6 | Babel's Streams | Scottish Psalter and Paraphrases | 1650 |
| 25b | Brimmer | Paul Gerhardt | 1656 |
| 111b | Judkins | Johann Frederick Hertzog | 1670 |
| 76b | Night | Johann Frederick Hertzog | 1670 |
| 468b | Laurell | John Milton | 1671 |
| 81t | Maitland | Thomas Shepherd | 1693 |
| 467t | Elparan | Joseph Stennett | 1663–1713 |
| 65 | The Golden Hill | Tate and Brady | 1696 |
| 412t | Howard | Tate and Brady | 1696 |
| 435 | Shenley | Tate and Brady | 1696 |
| 412b | Colchester | Tate and Brady | 1696 |
| 399b | Thatcher | Tate and Brady | 1696 |
| 210t | Old Hundred | Tate and Brady | 1696 |
| 468t | Mendon | Tate and Brady | 1696 |
| 469 | Pilesgrove | Tate and Brady | 1696 |
| 24b | Fredrica | Tate and Brady | 1696 |
| 444 | Broomsgrove | Tate and Brady | 1696 |
| 482 | Gray | Tate and Brady | 1696 |
| 136 | Sherburne | Nahum Tate | 1702 |
| 198 | News From The Skies | Isaac Watts | 1706 |
| 104 | Everlasting Song | Isaac Watts | 1706 |
| 171 | Sessions | Isaac Watts | 1706 |
| 430 | Let Me Rise | Isaac Watts | 1706 |
| 443 | Christmas | Isaac Watts | 1706 |
| 121b | Greensboro | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 160 | The Saint's Delight | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 432b | Fish Pond | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 480 | Salineville | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 145b | Fiducia | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 89 | Northfield | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 111t | Fleeting Days | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 158 | The Land of Rest | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 48 | Mount Helicon | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 135 | Raymond | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 144t | Tribulation | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 192 | The Penitent | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 393b | China | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 383 | Azmon | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 460b | Gratitude | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 44b | Dunlap's Creek | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 174t | Prospect | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 399t | Lockport | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 418b | Union Vale | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 46t | The Hill of Zion | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 36b | Albion | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 45t | Ila | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 105b | Hamburg | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 188 | He Loves Me | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 448b | Coleshill | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 59t | Mear | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 128b | Ninety-Fifth | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 445 | Revelation | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 156 | Repentance | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 35t | Lisbon | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 288 | Morris | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 125t | Endless Joy | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 436t | Turner | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 421b | Caddo | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 452b | Hebron | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 409t | Little Marlborough | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 63t | Condescension | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 51 | Lonsdale | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 476b | Shepherd (Second) | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 58b | Primrose | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 146b | Bangor | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 30t | Zion's Joy | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 432t | Loftin | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 472t | Sunset | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 90 | Brightest Days | Isaac Watts | 1707 |
| 456b | Endor | Isaac Watts | 1709 |
| 413b | Barby | Isaac Watts | 1709 |
| 450b | Consolation | Isaac Watts | 1709 |
| 61t | North Carolina | Isaac Watts | 1709 |
| 174b | Burning Lamp | Isaac Watts | 1709 |
| 447 | Mount Pisgah | Isaac Watts | 1709 |
| 67t | Peterboro | Isaac Watts | 1709 |
| 455b | Rockbridge | Isaac Watts | 1709 |
| 54 | My Trust | Isaac Watts | 1709 |
| 75 | Sprague | Isaac Watts | 1709 |
| 457t | Ware | Isaac Watts | 1709 |
| 209 | The Lord's Supper | Isaac Watts | 1709 |
| 207t | Windham | Isaac Watts | 1709 |
| 386 | Spartanburg | Joseph Addison | 1712 |
| 105t | Tender Care | Joseph Addison | 1712 |
| 94 | Plenary | Joseph Addison | 1712 |
| 390 | Crown of Light | Alexander Pope | 1712 |
| 464 | Reformation | John Denham | 1714 |
| 456t | Blenden | John Denham | 1714 |
| 128t | Hester | Isaac Watts | 1716 |
| 133 | Juniata | Philip Doddridge | 1717 |
| 429 | Charming Name | Philip Doddridge | 1717 |
| 494 | Hingham | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 413t | Warwick | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 462t | Lotha | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 519 | Dalston | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 408t | Shirland | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 541 | Resignation (Second) | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 472b | Cleaveland | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 123 | Rapturous Scene | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 491 | Nashville | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 462b | Upton | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 73b | Downs | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 62b | Joy to the World | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 420 | Cambridge | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 216t | O, Save | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 458 | Rolland | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 123 | Rapturous Scene | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 28b | Watchman (First) | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 490 | Creation (Second) | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 460t | Bohemia | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 219 | Rapture (First) | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 32t | Rayfield | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 161t | Wells | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 414 | Friend | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 489 | Ridge | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 70t | Arlington | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 32b | Zellville | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 492b | Supplication | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 449 | Cosmer | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 448t | Suffield | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 404t | Rosalie | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 536 | Symphony | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 159t | Devotion (First) | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 211b | Humble Penitent | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 107 | Resignation (First) | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 410b | Kambia | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 45b | Lofty Sky | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 422t | Boswell | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 290 | Amity | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 43 | The Heavenly Throng | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 398t | St. Thomas | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 459t | All-Saints | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 67b | Dundee | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 8 | Creation (First) | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 470 | Duke Street | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 26t | Golden Hill | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 398b | Gerar | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 140 | Edom | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 459b | Refuge | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 403b | Silver Street | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 478b | Sylvan Stream | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 195 | Garden | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 416b | Edwards | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 467b | Uxbridge | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 452t | Head | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 35b | Boylston | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 52 | Newburg | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 476t | Effingham | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 39 | A Precious Stone | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 126 | Ocean | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 521 | Darwell | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 256b | Sacred Rest | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 543 | Chase High Road | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 402b | Kelso | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 442 | Lanesboro | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 415b | Henry | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 520 | Harwich | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 227 | Majestic Rays | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 137 | Antioch | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 56t | America | Isaac Watts | 1719 |
| 483 | Burroughs (New) | Simon Browne | 1720 |
| 98 | Christian Soldier | Isaac Watts | 1724 |
| 148 | Leander | Isaac Watts | 1724 |
| 49 | Forever with the Lord | James Montgomery | 1735 |
| 473 | Bartholday | Philip Doddridge | 1736 |
| 225b | Martin | Charles Wesley | 1738 |
| 393t | West Point | Elizabeth Rowe | 1739 |
| 295 | Redeemer's Praise | Charles Wesley | 1739 |
| 419t | Rockingham (First) | Charles Wesley | 1739 |
| 479 | Triumph | Charles Wesley | 1739 |
| 61b | Gaines | Charles Wesley | 1739 |
| 300 | Desire | Charles Wesley | 1739 |
| 30b | Dennis | John Killinghall | 1741 |
| 161b | Awake, Jerusalem | Charles Wesley | 1741 |
| 76t | Brainerd | Charles Wesley | 1741 |
| 40b | Weeping Sinners | John Cennick | 1742 |
| 62t | Sweet Hope (First) | Charles Wesley | 1742 |
| 492t | Ramesis | Charles Wesley | 1742 |
| 199 | Vernon | Charles Wesley | 1742 |
| 548 | Macedonia | Charles Wesley | 1742 |
| 337 | To Die No More | John Cennick | 1743 |
| 217 | Jerusalem | John Cennick | 1743 |
| 211t | Hopewell | John Cennick | 1743 |
| 215 | In That Morning | John Cennick | 1743 |
| 416t | Fragrance | John Cennick | 1743 |
| 347 | Portuguese Hymn | John Francis Wade | 1743 |
| 508 | Heavenly Rest | Charles Wesley | 1744 |
| 21 | Webster | William Hammond | 1745 |
| 428 | Zerah | John Morrison | 1745 |
| 505 | Waterford | Charles Wesley | 1745 |
| 396t | Adams | Charles Wesley | 1745 |
| 516 | Oliphant | William Williams | 1745 |
| 294 | Carmarthen | Charles Wesley | 1746 |
| 500t | Harts | Charles Wesley | 1746 |
| 500b | Inley | Charles Wesley | 1746 |
| 455t | New Lebanon | Charles Wesley | 1747 |
| 510t | Aberdeen | Charles Wesley | 1747 |
| 529 | Worship | Charles Wesley | 1747 |
| 336t | Sweet Harmony | John Gambold | 1748 |
| 517 | Rapture (Second) | John Ogilvie | 1749 |
| 336b | Probation | Charles Wesley | 1749 |
| 283 | Willowby | Charles Wesley | 1749 |
| 471b | Hesperia | Charles Wesley | 1749 |
| 312 | Penitence | Charles Wesley | 1749 |
| 118 | Campbell | Charles Wesley | 1749 |
| 465t | Breaker | Charles Wesley | 1749 |
| 307 | True Happiness | Charles Wesley | 1749 |
| 44t | Morning Sun | Elizabeth Scott | 1708–1776 |
| 293 | Lenox | Charles Wesley | 1750 |
| 297 | Lucas | Charles Wesley | 1750 |
| 23t | Phillippi | Philip Doddridge | 1755 |
| 487 | Chester | Philip Doddridge | 1755 |
| 78t | Repent | Philip Doddridge | 1755 |
| 167t | Detroit | Philip Doddridge | 1755 |
| 31b | Time | Philip Doddridge | 1755 |
| 26b | Ninety-Third | Philip Doddridge | 1755 |
| 522 | Newbury | Philip Doddridge | 1755 |
| 103 | Derrick | Philip Doddridge | 1755 |
| 194 | O Happy Day | Philip Doddridge | 1755 |
| 415t | Nazareth | Philip Doddridge | 1755 |
| 193 | Kay | Philip Doddridge | 1755 |
| 50 | Cranbrook | Philip Doddridge | 1755 |
| 481 | Holden | Philip Doddridge | 1755 |
| 463 | Anvern | Philip Doddridge | 1755 |
| 218b | Harmony | Mary Masters | 1755 |
| 368b | Sweetest Pleasure | Mary Masters | 1755 |
| 281b | Palmetto | James Allen | 1757 |
| 259t | Crumly | James Allen | 1757 |
| 261t | Come Thou Fount | Robert Robinson | 1758 |
| 291 | Warrenton | Robert Robinson | 1758 |
| 259b | Olney | Robert Robinson | 1758 |
| 214 | Hosanna | Charles Wesley | 1758 |
| 74 | God's Helping Hand | Philip Doddridge | 1759 |
| 25t | Santee | Joseph Hart | 1759 |
| 233 | Believer and His Soul | Joseph Hart | 1759 |
| 256t | Pleading Savior | Joseph Hart | 1759 |
| 510b | Invitation | Joseph Hart | 1759 |
| 256t | Pleading Savior | John Leland | 1759 |
| 310b | Weary Sinner | Augustus M. Toplady | 1759 |
| 88 | Pisgah | Charles Wesley | 1759 |
| 433 | New Haven | Charles Wesley | 1759 |
| 157 | Hallelujah | Charles Wesley | 1759 |
| 92 | Promised Day | Charles Wesley | 1759 |
| 409b | Newingham | Charles Wesley | 1759 |
| 221t | Pleyel's Hymn | James Merrick | 1760 |
| 498 | Hendon | James Merrick | 1760 |
| 405t | Honeywel | Anne Steele | 1760 |
| 423t | Coventry | Anne Steele | 1760 |
| 434 | Nobler Choice | Anne Steele | 1760 |
| 423b | Benediction | Anne Steele | 1760 |
| 43 | The Heavenly Throng | Anne Steele | 1760 |
| 474 | Rothwell | Anne Steele | 1760 |
| 417t | Heber | Anne Steele | 1760 |
| 404b | Arion | Anne Steele | 1760 |
| 276 | Worlds Beyond the Sky | Anne Steele | 1760 |
| 140 | Edom | Anne Steele | 1760 |
| 431 | Dungeness | Anne Steele | 1760 |
| 478t | Brentford | Anne Steele | 1760 |
| 453b | Wakefield | Anne Steele | 1760 |
| 440b | Robinson | Anne Steele | 1760 |
| 66b | The Penitent's Prayer | Anne Steele | 1760 |
| 427 | Naomi | Anne Steele | 1760 |
| 123 | Rapturous Scene | Anne Steele | 1760 |
| 28t | Mocksville | Joseph Hart | 1762 |
| 394 | Stubborn Heart | Joseph Hart | 1762 |
| 344 | Morality | Hannah More | 1762 |
| 493t | Kedron | Charles Wesley | 1762 |
| 55t | Carolina | Charles Wesley | 1762 |
| 397t | Hants | Charles Wesley | 1762 |
| 218t | Cookham | M. Madan's Psalms and Hymns | 1763 |
| 55b | Idumea | Charles Wesley | 1763 |
| 281t | Am I Born to Die? | Charles Wesley | 1763 |
| 130b | Passing Away | Charles Wesley | 1763 |
| 424 | Nightingale | Ottiwell Heginbothom | 1744–1768 |
| 368t | Brush Creek | Joseph Grigg | 1765 |
| 185 | Corinth | Joseph Grigg | 1765 |
| 471t | Rockingham (Second) | James Merrick | 1765 |
| 306 | Middlebury | Charles Wesley | 1767 |
| 224b | Hark My Soul | William Cowper | 1768 |
| 71 | The Peaceful Shore | Thomas Gibbons | 1769 |
| 270 | Lena | Joseph Hart | 1769 |
| 496b | Resurrection | Thomas Scott | 1769 |
| 304 | Blue Vale of Naucoochee | Thomas Olivers | 1770 |
| 525 | Goodly Land | Thomas Olivers | 1770 |
| 232b | Olean | John Newton | 1771 |
| 417b | Zanesville | Anna Laetitia Barbauld | 1772 |
| 362 | Shining Light | William Cowper | 1772 |
| 151 | Sweet Prospect | William Cowper | 1772 |
| 419b | Fountain | William Cowper | 1772 |
| 425b | Ryland | William Cowper | 1772 |
| 144b | Walk with God | William Cowper | 1772 |
| 421t | Seymour | William Cowper | 1772 |
| 125b | Day Dawn | William Cowper | 1772 |
| 91 | There is a Fountain | William Cowper | 1772 |
| 241 | Closer Walk with God | William Cowper | 1772 |
| 401b | Euphrates | Augustus M. Toplady | 1772 |
| 406 | Luther | Augustus M. Toplady | 1772 |
| 512 | Missionary Song | William Williams | 1772 |
| 499t | Hasten Sinner | Thomas Scott | 1773 |
| 452t | Head | John Newton | 1725–1807 |
| 208t | He Lives | Samuel Medley | 1775 |
| 226t | Rock of Ages | Augustus M. Toplady | 1776 |
| 311 | Elysian | Richard Kempenfelt | 1777 |
| 496t | Wilmot | Benjamin Williams | 1778 |
| 163t | Hollis | William Cowper | 1779 |
| 234 | The Singing Christian | William Cowper | 1779 |
| 546t | The Holy Spirit | William Cowper | 1779 |
| 145t | Milledgeville | William Cowper | 1779 |
| 69 | Rocky Mount | John Newton | 1779 |
| 451b | Devotion (Second) | John Newton | 1779 |
| 73t | Ella's Song | John Newton | 1779 |
| 100 | Tennessee | John Newton | 1779 |
| 260b | Shields | John Newton | 1779 |
| 507b | Sicily | John Newton | 1779 |
| 249 | Green Fields | John Newton | 1779 |
| 382 | How Sweet the Sound | John Newton | 1779 |
| 236t | Pacolet | John Newton | 1779 |
| 246 | The Good Physician | John Newton | 1779 |
| 395 | King of Peace | John Newton | 1779 |
| 440t | Beulah | John Newton | 1779 |
| 187 | The Gospel Pool | John Newton | 1779 |
| 78b | New Britain | John Newton | 1779 |
| 532 | Boerne | John Newton | 1779 |
| 269t | Restoration | John Newton | 1779 |
| 86t | Ortonville | John Newton | 1779 |
| 221b | Poor, Weak, and Worthless | John Newton | 1779 |
| 254t | Bartimeus | John Newton | 1779 |
| 63b | Pardoning Love | John Newton | 1779 |
| 401t | Tillotson | John Newton | 1779 |
| 129 | Coronation | Edward Perronet | 1779 |
| 79 | Kingwood | Thomas Greene | 1780 |
| 425t | Exchange | Charles Wesley | 1780 |
| 66t | Balerma | Michael Bruce | 1781 |
| 405b | Caution | George Heath | 1781 |
| 22t | Laban | George Heath | 1781 |
| 99 | Pleasant Hill | John Fawcett | 1782 |
| 400t | Christian Love | John Fawcett | 1782 |
| 53 | No Parting There | John Fawcett | 1782 |
| 123 | Rapturous Scene | Samuel Medley | 1782 |
| 196 | Loving Kindness | Samuel Medley | 1782 |
| 43 | The Heavenly Throng | Samuel Medley | 1782 |
| 315 | David's Victory | Hannah More | 1782 |
| 203 | Cumberland | Henry Alline | 1783 |
| 497t | Acton | George Burder | 1784 |
| 332 | Babylonian Captivity | Joel Barlow | 1785 |
| 410t | Weeping Saviour | Benjamin Beddome | 1787 |
| 41t | Mediation | Benjamin Beddome | 1787 |
| 150 | Salvation | Edmund Jones | 1787 |
| 147 | Fairfield | Edmund Jones | 1787 |
| 338t | How Firm a Foundation | Rippon's Selection | 1787 |
| 113 | The Converted Thief | Samuel Stennett | 1787 |
| 437 | The Dying Penitent | Samuel Stennett | 1787 |
| 72t | Jordan | Samuel Stennett | 1787 |
| 87 | The Promised Land | Samuel Stennett | 1787 |
| 400b | Hall | Samuel Stennett | 1787 |
| 446 | Damascus | Samuel Stennett | 1787 |
| 152b | Messiah | Samuel Stennett | 1787 |
| 282 | Friendship | Bidwell | 1789 |
| 518 | Ariel | Samuel Medley | 1789 |
| 380 | Christian Song | Abner Reed | 1789 |
| 11 | Minister's Farewell | Broaddus and Broaddus, Collection of Sacred Ballads | 1790 |
| 5t | Dear Friends, Farewell | Broaddus and Broaddus, Collection of Sacred Ballads | 1790 |
| 391 | Glad Tidings | Maria DeFleury | 1773–1791 |
| 23b | Evening Hymn | John Leland | 1790 |
| 530 | Urmund | Samuel Medley | 1790 |
| 507t | Union | Thomas Baldwin | 1791 |
| 47 | Panting for Heaven | Maria DeFleury | 1791 |
| 339 | Samanthra | Joseph Swain | 1791 |
| 338b | Davis | Joseph Swain | 1791 |
| 484 | Olivet | Anna Laetitia Barbauld | 1792 |
| 497b | Horton | Anna Laetitia Barbauld | 1792 |
| 450t | Burford | Thomas Haweis | 1792 |
| 226b | Haws | Thomas Haweis | 1792 |
| 499b | Rosefield | Thomas Haweis | 1792 |
| 299 | Green Meadows | Elder Daniel Hibbard | 1792 |
| 378 | Mount Hope | Thomas Odiorne | 1792 |
| 57 | Salvation's Rock | Joseph Swain | 1792 |
| 16 | The Finest Flower | Joseph Swain | 1792 |
| 164b | The Pilgrim's Song | Clay's Hymns and Spiritual Songs | 1793 |
| 235 | Faithful Soldier | John Leland | 1793 |
| 247 | Oh! How Charming | John Leland | 1793 |
| 232t | Heavenly Armor | John Leland | 1793 |
| 244t | Mutual Love | John Leland | 1793 |
| 269b | Invocation | Peak's New Collection | 1793 |
| 36t | Lovely Vine | Smith and Sleeper's Divine Hymns | 1794 |
| 159b | Long Sought Home | Joseph Bromehead | 1795 |
| 340 | Concord | Benjamin Francis | 1795 |
| 438 | The Mouldering Vine (Second) | Selah Gridley | 1795 |
| 271 | The Mouldering Vine (First) | Selah Gridley | 1795 |
| 454 | Heavenly Light (or Eden) | William Shrubsole | 1796 |
| 27b | Missionary Herald | Bourne Hall Draper | 1797 |
| 132 | Musical Society | The American Musical Miscellany | 1798 |
| 102 | Missionary's Adieu | William Ward | 1799 |
| 223 | Hallelujah! Praise The Lord | Samuel Pearce | 1800 |
| 277 | Sweet Affliction | Samuel Pearce | 1800 |
| 134 | Liberty | The Musical Harmonist | 1800 |
| 257 | Jubilee | Baltimore Collection | 1801 |
| 121t | Prosperity | Baltimore Collection | 1801 |
| 361 | Solemn Thought | Goddard's New and Beautiful Collection | 1801 |
| 114 | That Glorious Day | John Leland | 1801 |
| 115 | The Millennium | John Leland | 1801 |
| 286 | Ganges | Samson Occom | 1801 |
| 124 | Pilgrim's Triumph | John Adam Granade | 1802 |
| 280 | Zion | Thomas Kelly | 1802 |
| 41b | Ardor | Thomas Kelly | 1802 |
| 58t | Liverpool | Selection of Hymns and Spiritual Songs | 1803 |
| 441 | The Lonesome Dove | John Adam Granade | 1804 |
| 108 | Redeeming Love | John Adam Granade | 1804 |
| 10 | Zion's Dove | John Adam Granade | 1804 |
| 119 | Weary Souls | John Adam Granade | 1804 |
| 106 | Sweet Rivers | John Adam Granade | 1804 |
| 330 | Fulfillment | John Adam Granade | 1804 |
| 190 | Salutation | Caleb Jarvis Taylor | 1804 |
| 319 | Weary Pilgrim | Caleb Jarvis Taylor | 1804 |
| 266 | Chrystler's Field | Courtney's Christian Pocket Companion | 1805 |
| 17 | Call to Arms | Courtney's Christian Pocket Companion | 1805 |
| 408b | Dartmouth | Dr. Watts's Psalms and Hymns | 1805 |
| 127 | Herald | Bourne Hall Draper | 1805 |
| 155 | Solemn Call | Hymns, Original and Selected | 1805 |
| 101 | An Address for All | Hymns, Original and Selected | 1805 |
| 265 | Mourner's Lamentation | Ingalls's Christian Harmony | 1805 |
| 245 | Bozrah | Meyer's Collection of Hymns | 1805 |
| 350 | The Rock | Rev. John Price | 1805 |
| 258 | Thorny Desert | The Lexington Collection | 1805 |
| 216b | Social Band | John Poage Campbell | 1806 |
| 475 | Portugal | William Bengo Collyer | 1806 |
| 477 | Park Street | Dobell's New Selection | 1806 |
| 40b | Weeping Sinners | Oliver Holden | 1806 |
| 81t | Maitland | Hymns & Spiritual Songs | 1806 |
| 264 | Harwell | Thomas Kelly | 1806 |
| 222b | St. Louis | Henry Kirke White | 1806 |
| 549t | The Christian's Farewell | Thomas Cleland | 1807 |
| 110 | Volunteers | John Adam Granade | 1807 |
| 411 | The Trumpeters | John Adam Granade | 1807 |
| 272 | Felicity | John Leland | 1807 |
| 231 | Indian's Farewell | Anna Jane Vardill | 1807 |
| 514 | Crown | Thomas Kelly | 1809 |
| 485 | Quito | Thomas Kelly | 1809 |
| 207b | Meditation | William Miller | 1809 |
| 191 | Oh! Turn, Sinner | William Miller | 1809 |
| 509b | The Good Shepherd | John Adam Granade | 1810 |
| 252 | The Sufferings of Christ | Mercer's Cluster | 1810 |
| 392 | Imandra | Mercer's Cluster | 1810 |
| 153 | Columbus | Mercer's Cluster | 1810 |
| 192 | The Penitent | Gerard Noel | 1810 |
| 396b | Waynsville | William Goode | 1811 |
| 465b | Welton | William Goode | 1811 |
| 321 | Hear and Save | Reginald Heber | 1811 |
| 346 | Star in the East | Reginald Heber | 1811 |
| 345 | The Shepherd's Star | Reginald Heber | 1811 |
| 342 | Blest Morn | Reginald Heber | 1811 |
| 95 | Canaan's Land | Lloyd's Hymns on Select Passages of Scripture | 1811 |
| 210b | Contented Soldier | John MacMillan | 1811 |
| 359 | Wondrous Love | Mead's General Selection | 1811 |
| 318 | The Martial Trumpet | Caleb Jarvis Taylor | 1811 |
| 254b | Talmar | William Bengo Collyer | 1812 |
| 493b | Day-Star | William Bengo Collyer | 1812 |
| 229 | Tranquility | Thomas Raffles | 1812 |
| 165 | Babylon is Fallen | Richard McNemar | 1813 |
| 329 | Redeeming Grace | Wyeth's Repository, Part 2nd | 1813 |
| 292 | Grief of Love | Battle's Collection | 1814 |
| 146t | Solemn Warning | Battle's Collection | 1814 |
| 287 | Indian Convert | T. D. C. | 1814 |
| 243 | Zion's Light | John Poage Campbell | 1814 |
| 201 | Mission | Chase's Divine Songs | 1814 |
| 353 | Bower of Prayer | John Osborn | circa 1815 |
| 314 | The Christian | Caleb Jarvis Taylor | 1815 |
| 59b | Dove of Peace | William Maxwell | 1816 |
| 513 | Lakeland | James Montgomery | 1816 |
| 116 | Floyd | Thomas Moore | 1816 |
| 242 | Come, Ye Disconsolate | Thomas Moore | 1816 |
| 5b | Always Something New | Shirley's Select Collection | 1816 |
| 93 | Something New | Shirley's Select Collection | 1816 |
| 323 | Holy Manna | George Askins | 1817 |
| 200 | Parting Hand | John Blain | 1818 |
| 535 | Trial's Hour | Josiah Conder | 1818 |
| 366 | Millennium (First) | Foster's Hymns and Spiritual Songs | 1818 |
| 204b | Evening Bells | Thomas Moore | 1818 |
| 426 | Tappan | William Bingham Tappan | 1818 |
| 262 | Collins | George Askins | 1819 |
| 27t | Morning Worship | Phoebe Hinsdale Brown | 1819 |
| 534 | Angels Singing | John Cawood | 1819 |
| 537 | Crucifixion | Kolb's Spiritual Songster | 1819 |
| 504 | Missionary Hymn | Reginald Heber | 1821 |
| 538 | Isles of the South | William Bingham Tappan | 1822 |
| 326 | Royal Proclamation | Wilson Thompson | circa 1822 |
| 524 | When Shall We Meet Again? | Isaac Watts | 1822 |
| 244b | The Christian's Conflicts | A Selection of Hymns and Spiritual Songs | 1823 |
| 230b | Amboy | Leonard Bacon | 1823 |
| 486b | Lisle | John Bowring | 1823 |
| 263 | Autumn | Dr. Thomas Hastings | 1823 |
| 351 | Sweet Home | John Howard Payne | 1823 |
| 70b | Brown | Phoebe Hinsdale Brown | 1824 |
| 260t | Bavaria | Henry Francis Lyte | 1824 |
| 250b | Disciple | Henry Francis Lyte | 1824 |
| 154 | Happy Time | Hymns, Psalms, and Spiritual Songs | 1825 |
| 501 | Owen | James Montgomery | 1825 |
| 509t | Break of Day | James Montgomery | 1825 |
| 511 | Farewell | Moore's Columbian Harmony | 1825 |
| 327 | The Christian's Hope | Social and Camp-Meeting Songs | 1825 |
| 13 | Traveler's Hope | Social and Camp-Meeting Songs | 1825 |
| 360 | The Saints Bound for Heaven | Social and Camp-Meeting Songs | 1825 |
| 388 | Anchor | Evangelical Magazine Supplement | 1826 |
| 24t | Volusia | William Augustus Muhlenberg | 1826 |
| 354 | Summer | William Augustus Muhlenberg | 1826 |
| 402t | Olive Leaf | William Augustus Muhlenberg | 1826 |
| 397b | Bedan | William Augustus Muhlenberg | 1826 |
| 22b | Sinner Come | Henry Ustick Onderdonk | 1826 |
| 389 | Crown of Victory | Sarah Elizabeth Miles | 1827 |
| 357 | The Trumpet | H. H. Milman | 1827 |
| 317 | The Christian Soldier | Charlotte Elizabeth | 1828 |
| 85 | Mercy Seat | Hugh Stowell | 1828 |
| 488 | Dell of the Woods | Hugh Stowell | 1828 |
| 486t | Retreat | Hugh Stowell | 1828 |
| 466 | The Mercy-Seat | Hugh Stowell | 1828 |
| 313 | Bruce's Address | Jared B. Waterbury | 1828 |
| 418t | Chimes | Harriet Auber | 1829 |
| 502 | Eton | Harriet Auber | 1829 |
| 230t | Eltham | Harriet Auber | 1829 |
| 250t | Realms of the Blest | Elizabeth King Mills | 1829 |
| 495 | The Sailor's Home | Seaman's Devotional Assistant | 1830 |
| 523 | Conquest | A Selection of Hymns | 1831 |
| 457b | Evening Chant | William Hiley Bathurst | 1831 |
| 80 | The Blind Girl | Samuel G. Goodrich | 1831 |
| 503 | Invocation (New) | Leavitt's Christian Lyre, vol. 2 | 1831 |
| 451t | Shepherd (First) | Mason and Greene's Church Psalmody | 1831 |
| 222t | Praise | W. Wrangham | 1831 |
| 242 | Come, Ye Disconsolate | Dr. Thomas Hastings | 1832 |
| 461 | Lynn | Margaret Mackay | 1832 |
| 168t | Rest | Margaret Mackay | 1832 |
| 240 | Morning Light | Samuel Francis Smith | 1832 |
| 237 | Remember Thy Creator | Samuel Francis Smith | 1832 |
| 225t | Kenan | Samuel Francis Smith | 1832 |
| 275 | Missionary's Farewell | Samuel Francis Smith | 1832 |
| 545 | Mount Vernon | Samuel Francis Smith | 1832 |
| 365 | The Indian's Petition | John Perry | 1833 |
| 524 | When Shall We Meet Again? | Samuel Francis Smith | 1833 |
| 29 | The Midnight Cry | Baptist Harmony | 1834 |
| 515 | Olive Shade | Felicia Dorothea Browne Hemans | 1834 |
| 364 | Redemption (Second) | Millard's Hymns and Spiritual Songs | 1834 |
| 142 | The Solid Rock | Edward Mote | 1834 |
| 533 | Prospect of Heaven | Charles Giles | 1835 |
| 86b | Hicks' Farewell | Rev. Berryman Hicks | 1835 |
| 267 | Louisiana | Southern Harmony | 1835 |
| 236b | Complainer | Southern Harmony | 1835 |
| 152t | Cross of Christ | Southern Harmony | 1835 |
| 363 | The Christian Warfare | Southern Harmony | 1835 |
| 205 | The Watchman's Call | Southern Harmony | 1835 |
| 325t | Will You Go? | Pious Songs | 1836 |
| 328 | Mercy's Free | Pious Songs | 1836 |
| 130t | Sacred Love | John Reynell Wreford | 1837 |
| 341 | The Lone Pilgrim | Elder John Ellis | 1838 |
| 212 | Christian Prospect | The Knoxville Harmony | 1838 |
| 289 | Happy Land | Andrew Young | 1838 |
| 56b | Sing to Me of Heaven | Mary Stanley Bunce Dana Shindler | 1840 |
| 527 | Prince of Light | H. G. O. Dwight | 1803–1862 |
| 239t | Soft Music | Mary Stanley Bunce Dana Shindler | 1841 |
| 335 | When I am Gone | Mary Stanley Bunce Dana Shindler | 1841 |
| 506 | Dying Love | William Maxwell | 1842 |
| 163b | Burroughs | Revival Melodies | 1842 |
| 81t | Maitland | Second Advent Hymns | 1842 |
| 331 | A Home in Heaven | Dr. William Hunter | 1843 |
| 46b | Waiting Church | Horatius Bonar | 1845 |
| 238 | Child's Wish | Sidney P. Gill | 1845 |
| 179 | Traveling On | Dr. William Hunter | 1845 |
| 542 | The Heavenly Home | Dr. William Hunter | 1845 |
| 268 | Come Ye to the Waters | The Southern and Western Pocket Harmonist | 1845 |
| 206 | Prayer Meeting | W. W. Walford | 1845 |
| 1 | Weary Rest | Horatius Bonar | 1846 |
| 139 | The Wanderer's Grave | Rufus B. Sage | 1846 |
| 102 | Missionary's Adieu | J. Lewis Shuck | 1812–1863 |
| 208b | French Broad | William Walker | 1847 |
| 2 | O Wondrous Love | Cecil Frances Alexander | 1848 |
| 549b | The Drone | Hendrickson's Union Harmony | 1848 |
| 403t | New Year | The Harp of Columbia | 1848 |
| 358 | O Come, Come Away | The Hesperian Harp | 1848 |
| 526 | Zion's Glory | Samuel Francis Smith | circa 1850 |
| 96 | Mighty Love | G. W. Treadway | 1850 |
| 355 | Homeward Bound | William Fairfield Warren | 1850 |
| 356 | Morning Song | Bradbury's Musical Gems for School and Home | 1851 |
| 539 | Rest for the Weary | Dr. William Hunter | 1811–1877 |
| 333 | Night is Coming | Anna Louisa Walker Cognill | 1854 |
| 239b | I Want to Be an Angel | Sidney P. Gill | 1854 |
| 422b | Whitney | Mason's Hallelujah | 1854 |
| 122 | The Dying Boy | Nettie Lynn | 1855 |
| 309 | Singing School | J. H. Moss | 1855 |
| 193 | Kay | Social Harp | 1855 |
| 175 | O How I Love Jesus | Frederick Whitfield | 1855 |
| 539 | Rest for the Weary | Samuel Young Harmer | 1856 |
| 255 | Watchman (Second) | Sidney Smith Brewer | 1857 |
| 310t | Our Journey Home | William H. Langston | 1811–1886 |
| 242 | Come, Ye Disconsolate | Dr. E. M. Pendleton | 1815–1884 |
| 387 | Stay, Sinner | Rev. W. Kenney | 1859 |
| 117 | Angel Band | Rev. Jefferson Haskell | 1860 |
| 436b | It Is I | Asaph, or The Choir Book | 1861 |
| 285 | Farewell Brother | Edmund Hamilton Sears | 1862 |
| 546b | Oak Grove | T. J. “Stonewall” Jackson | 1863 |
| 348 | We've a Mansion in Heaven | Mary Ann Kidder | 1864 |
| 343 | Tell the Story | Katherine Hankey | 1866 |
| 31t | Home | The Christian Harmony | 1867 |
| 164t | Convict | The Christian Harmony | 1867 |
| 228 | Pass Me Not | Fannie J. Crosby | 1868 |
| 274 | Mother Tell Me of the Angels | Fresh Leaves for the Use of Sabbath Schools | 1868 |
| 324 | Fair Fields of Eden | Rev. A. H. Lester | 1828–1897 |
| 97 | The Guiding Star | Rev. R. W. Fain | 1873 |
| 248 | Twilight is Falling | A. S. Kieffer | 1877 |
| 82t | Lady Touch Thy Harp Again | F. L. Stanton | 1881 |
| 180 | The Sinless Summerland | J. W. Welsh | 1883 |
| 303 | The Unclouded Day | J. K. Alwood | 1885 |
| 37 | Heaven's My Home | A. J. Showalter | 1889 |
| 178 | That Beautiful Land | H. E. Engle | 1890 |
| 253 | Is It Far? | John B. Vaughan | 1890 |
| 162 | Redeemed Singers | John B. Vaughan | 1898 |
| 189 | One by One | A. J. Showalter | 1858–1924 |
| 109 | Not Made with Hands | John S. Brown | 1900 |
| 284 | Don't Grieve Your Mother | F. M. Graham | 1900 |
| 60 | What Did He Do? | James M. Gray | 1903 |
| 544 | Life's Troubles | Hugh McGraw | 1903 |
| 170 | On My Way | James Rowe | 1865–1933 |
| 325b | Jesus Died For Me | P. A. Cofer | 1909 |
| 143 | Farther Along | W. B. Stevens | 1862–1943 |
| 220 | Over the Sea | Missionary Gems | 1913 |
| 184 | Where We'll Never Grow Old | James C. Moore | 1914 |
| 77 | How Beautiful Heaven Must Be | Mrs. A. S. Bridgewater | 1920 |
| 82b | Gospel Waves | Mrs. E. G. Floyd | 1920 |
| 74 | God's Helping Hand | Feriba Dunagan | 1885–1952 |
| 261b | Alone | T. W. Loftin | 1874–1967 |
| 182 | A Happy Meeting | O. A. Parris | 1929 |
| 372 | I Won't Turn Back | S. Whitt Denson | 1890–1964 |
| 68 | Bright Mansions | H. A. Parris | 1935 |
| 168b | Sunrise | O. A. Parris | 1941 |
| 3 | Christmas Morning | H. A. Parris | 1944 |
| 131 | Will You Meet Me? | O. A. Parris | 1946 |
| 278 | God Holds the Future | T. M. Stevens | 1900–1975 |
| 176 | Heavenly Treasures | Chris Chastain | 1952 |
| 4 | Copeland | H. P. Copeland | 1954 |
| 7 | Jehovah is My God | S. Whitt Denson | 1954 |
| 308 | The Happy Time | John Dunagan | 1954 |
| 19 | The Day of Days | Victor Hamner | 1954 |
| 167b | Come Along | John T. Hocutt | 1954 |
| 64 | Youthful Blessings | Morgan D. Jones | 1954 |
| 42 | Joy Bells | H. A. Parris | 1954 |
| 14 | I'll Serve My Lord | O. A. Parris | 1954 |
| 34 | Going Home | O. A. Parris | 1954 |
| 305 | The Weary Soldier | O. A. Parris | 1954 |
| 149 | A Good Time Coming | O. A. Parris | 1954 |
| 12 | Gate of Home | O. A. Parris | 1954 |
| 322 | Among that Band | O. A. Parris | 1954 |
| 20 | Prison Chains | O. A. Parris | 1954 |
| 320 | Longing for the Day | O. A. Parris | 1954 |
| 9 | Cords of Love | O. A. Parris | 1954 |
| 197 | The Living Vine | O. A. Parris | 1954 |
| 172 | The Grand Highway | O. A. Parris | 1954 |
| 166 | What Can I Do? | O. A. Parris | 1954 |
| 296 | He's Holding My Hand | O. A. Parris | 1954 |
| 15 | My Consolation | Coy Putnam | 1954 |
| 38 | God Is Our Refuge | Arthur L. Deason | 1958 |
| 186 | Lord Remember Me | John H. Deason | 1958 |
| 33 | Angel Choir | E. Foy Frederick | 1958 |
| 81b | Eternal Joys | John T. Hocutt | 1958 |
| 18 | Praise Our Redeemer | John T. Hocutt | 1958 |
| 316 | This Heavy Load | John T. Hocutt | 1958 |
| 187 | The Gospel Pool | O. A. Parris | 1958 |
| 204t | What a Day | William B. Rigdon | 1958 |
| 47 | Panting for Heaven | The Christian Harmony | 1958 |
| 334 | Jordan's Stormy Wave | Rev. J. C. Wisener | 1958 |
| 138 | Rest in the Kingdom | C. B. Woodard | 1958 |
| 298 | My Shepherd Guides | Era Tidwell Godsey | 1959 |
| 349 | Redemption (First) | John T. Hocutt | 1959 |
| 385 | Sweet Heaven | Arthur L. Deason | 1909–2009 |
| 213 | Be Committed | Eva B. Lloyd | 1967 |
| 279 | Lecil | Mrs. Elsie McCullar | 1914–2006 |
| 273 | Sing His Praise | Carver Deason | 1912–2011 |
| 352 | My Home on High | William B. Rigdon | 1931–1995 |
| 84 | Homeland | William B. Rigdon | 1931–1995 |
| 384 | Lord I'm Depending on You | Mrs. Thurman Byrd | 1924–2003 |
| 120 | Home in the Sky | John T. Hocutt | 1994 |
| 40t | Mamie | John T. Hocutt | 1994 |
| 547 | Higher Ground | John Newton Merritt | 2000 |